Our first venture to Olea in New Haven was a delightful experience, with a couple of outstanding dishes and one I did not enjoy.

As you approach the restaurant via your GPS, take note, as there is very little flare to the exterior, a nice, simple entrance on the right side of the street. Once inside, you will enjoy a refined, yet vibrant decor, tables to the left and in the rear, which share its space with a large bar area, fully alive with patrons. We were lucky to have a great table in the middle of the room.
We started with two appetizers, the Tuna Tartare ($18), described as yellowfin tuna, tomato, ginger, soy sauce, sesame seeds, aioli, crispy wonton and the Pulpo ($17), which was Spanish octopus a la plancha, potato foam, celery, sweet piquillo pepper, tomato, capers, and paprika.
The tuna tartare was a nice mound of chopped tuna with a few wontons on the side. The tuna was fresh, fragrant and benefitted from a mild soy sauce accompaniment. It was a great start to the evening and I give it a good solid 9. The Octopus was one large tentacle with an enormous amount of foam. The small end of the tentacle was vastly overcooked, the thicker end was much better. I basically left the skinny end of the tentacle and really enjoyed the other end. The foam was more a stew of ingredients. I liked the potato aspect of the foam, but not as much a fan of the grape tomatoes that was a detriment to the dish. I give the pulpo dish an 8

For my entrée, I ordered the Scallops ($35), which were pan seared scallops, cauliflower, potato, ají amarillo, puffed quinoa, bell pepper-mango vinaigrette. The five scallops were medium sized, seared on one side with a stringy texture and not exceptionally flavorful, lacked succulence, and were very disappointing. They sat atop a molded (cauliflower) cake with the first bite overwhelmingly citrusy. The sauce was very nice and there were numerous textures with the diced veggies and puffed quinoa. Given the disappointment of the scallops and the way too citrussy cauliflower cake, I can only give this dish a 5.

Looking to rally after the scallops, we ordered the Chocolate Textures ($14) for dessert. This included a chocolate mousse-vanilla ice cream sandwich, milk chocolate rice crispy, chocolate-hazelnut ice cream, nougatine, white chocolate soup (spoiler alert, this contains alcohol). The dessert was the major hit of the evening. I started with the ice-cream sandwich, and it was delicious, and then moved to the crispy, which was even better. The single scoop of ice cream was also delicious. This was a complete homerun at a 10
In addition to the ordered items above, Olea also offers bread, which was very good, as well as a small potato croquette pre-dinner which was also good.
I had very high hopes for Olea. Some dishes were excellent, but on the next visit I will definitely avoid the scallops.



