Let’s just say it… il Buco al Mare is the best restaurant in the Hamptons. This is a very strong statement given the number of culinary options, but after numerous visits, I stand by that statement…every visit has been perfect in every aspect. The food is impeccable from the preparation to the plating and most importantly to the flavors, there is perfection in every step. Add to this the vibrant interior space and the relaxing garden out back and this is a spot for a casual shared dinner or a special occasion.
On this last visit, it was a cold June evening, and we braved the low 60s temperature and sat in the garden. The server approached promptly to take drink orders, and we simultaneously asked for the mushroom focaccia, we had to get the evening started.
Over the next two hours, our table enjoyed six incredible dishes.
The focaccia was topped with roasted eggplant, tomato, fresh mozzarella, anchovy, peperoncino and oregano ($25). This is no ordinary focaccia, which is normally cut and served in a basket, but il Buco’s was the love child of focaccia and pizza. It resembles a pizza with extremely puffy edges and a circle of goodness in the center. The crust was delicious, and the toppings were fantastic. I could make a meal of a flight of every focaccia on the menu. A great start for the meal and an easy 10.
We next moved to the main event with a pasta, two entrées and a couple of sides.
For our pasta choice, we opted for the Spaghetti with bottarga, peperoncino, garlic, lemon and parsley ($30). We are big fans of bottarga, a cured fish roe and the combination looked great, and it was. The pasta was cooked perfectly to al dente and the light, citrusy sauce exploded with every bite, plus a little saltiness from the bottarga. Another 10.
The star of the evening was the Smoked Senat chicken with cilantro chermoula, Tokyo turnips, labneh and berbere oil ($46). I consider this dish the best chicken in the Hamptons, in NY, and in America, yes, it is that good. A large, half chicken was carved into four pieces, leg, thigh and a split breast, smoked and roasted to a deep golden hue. The meat absorbed loads of smokiness and remained super moist, and the crispy skin was brilliant. Add a few of the accouterments (I loved the tiny Tokyo turnips) to each bite and experience numerous flavor combinations and textures. I could go on raving about this dish forever. I obviously give this dish a 10+++
The other entrée we ordered was the Skirt steak, chimichurri + sunchokes ($45), which was a nice 8–10-ounce portion, served with a bright and fragrant chimichurri and small halved sunchokes. Skirt steak is very underrated, but it is one of my favorite cuts since it delivers so much flavor. The meat was expertly prepared to our medium-rare / medium request and was full of deep flavors. The chimichurri was bright and fragrant and complemented the richness of the steak perfectly. This dish was an easy 9, it was great but it was sitting next to perfection.
We ordered two sides, the first was the crispy cannellini beans, celery, parsley and lemon ($18). The beans portion was a little smaller than we have received in the past, but the beans were delicious, crispy on the outside and still moist and soft on the interior. I give the cannellini beans a 9 (I wanted more).
Our second side was the Broccolini with lemon and chili ($18). We always ask about the spice level when we see chili and were told it was not that spicy. The spice level was better described as negligible, the earthiness of the large portion of broccolini was outstanding. This dish deserved a 10, which may be a first for me.
Service was even better than impeccable, rare that there was not a single slip, even minor, by any of the staff.
Overall, this was a perfect dinner in a perfect setting with perfect food and perfect service.
231 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930
Phone: (631) 557-3100
Jfood Eats 